Everyone knows that the Atlanta Braves are going to be actively pursuing starting pitching at the upcoming trade deadline. The only real question is exactly how aggressive they will be, and we won't have the answer to that until the team gets a better sense of what they have in AJ Smith-Shawver, JR Ritchie, and Owen Murphy. However, there is one trade candidate that has been floated as a fit for the Braves that they should probably avoid.
We know that Alex Anthopoulos likes to trade for guys that have team control beyond the current season at the deadline. Sure, he will dabble with rentals sometimes, but we have seen time and time again that this Braves front office sees the trade deadline as a way to get a head start on their offseason shopping list, and you can bet that rotation help would be on that list as well.
However, despite the fact that the Mariners are currently shopping veteran starter Luis Castillo at the trade deadline, the Braves may want to steer clear.
Luis Castillo is (probably) not the starting pitcher the Braves should be looking for at the trade deadline
At issue here is that Castillo is not the pitcher he once was, and he has been trending in the wrong direction for several years. His strikeout rate has been declining every year since 2023, his average fastball velocity is down almost two full miles per hour after formerly averaging 97 MPH, and he isn't nearly as proficient at limiting hard contact anymore. The end result has been a disappointing season where he has posted a 4.93 ERA and 4.16 FIP across 87.2 innings.
If the Braves were in a position where they only needed a warm body AND the Mariners were willing to eat a significant portion of the $24+ million a year that he will get through at least 2027, then maybe trading Castillo would be interesting. However, Atlanta needs actual rotation upgrades right now, and when you look at the current version of Castillo, it is honestly unclear if he actually would be one, especially when you think about the fact that he pitches home games in one of the more pitcher-friendly parks in all of baseball.
Now, does that mean that the Braves should pass on ANY trade for Castillo? No. If Seattle is itching to move on and will eat a lot of the remaining money left on his deal while not requiring a top prospect in return, then that could be a decent starting point for talks that wouldn't impact the Braves' ability to make other moves at the deadline. However, anything more than that should be a deal that Anthopoulos should approach with extreme caution.
Add us as a preferred source on Google