Skip to main content

Ranking all of the Braves’ contracts from worst to best ahead of a likely lockout

ByEric Cole
Oct 4, 2026; Los Angeles, California, USA;  Atlanta Braves catcher Sean Murphy (12) reacts after striking out with the bases loaded to end the first inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers in game two of the NLDS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Uniqlo Field at Dodger Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images
Oct 4, 2026; Los Angeles, California, USA; Atlanta Braves catcher Sean Murphy (12) reacts after striking out with the bases loaded to end the first inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers in game two of the NLDS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Uniqlo Field at Dodger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

There is a lot of uncertainty ahead of the MLB lockout. Not only are baseball fans and experts alike concerned about how long the work stoppage could last, but they are also anxious about what the game of baseball will look like afterwards. For teams like the Atlanta Braves with several guaranteed contracts on their books, the situation is particularly troublesome.

For the moment, it appears likely that the Braves wouldn't have to change much under the MLBPA's proposal or if the league gets their way. However, that doesn't mean they shouldn’t assess the contracts on their payroll and figure out which to prioritize keeping around going forward, just in case things get...weird.

Here are all of the Braves' contracts from worst to best (other than their pre-arbitration and arbitration-eligible players)

Importantly, pre-arbitration and arbitration players are not under consideration here. Most would agree that pre-arb and arbitration salaries are overwhelmingly team-friendly, and we don't actually know what those players are going to make each year. Given the variability and that arbitration is such a different animal, the focus here will instead be on the players on guaranteed deals.

13. Jurickson Profar

There isn't really an argument for anyone else in the bottom spot than Jurickson Profar. There is a nonzero chance that even if he shows up to camp ready to play, he will just get suspended again and leave the Braves hanging. In some respects, that would be ideal, because that would mean the Braves don't have to pay him another dime.

12. Austin Riley

This one hurts, but there is no denying that Austin Riley's future is in question right now. His numbers are all trending in the wrong direction, and it is starting to feel like his injuries have altered his body in a fundamental way that he cannot figure out how to get the most out of anymore. Not exactly what you want from a guy whom the Braves owe $22 million a year through 2032.

11. Sean Murphy

There is an argument for Murphy being a worse player than Riley right now, especially if Murphy can't figure out how to stay off the injured list. While paying $15 million a year to a backup catcher isn't ideal, the Braves can at least move on after the 2028 season, or exercise their option for 2029 if he starts to turn things around.

10. Spencer Strider

Strider is in a similar bucket to Murphy, in that he has dealt with a lot of injuries, is making real money, and his contract runs out after 2028 with a club option for 2029. However, Strider's upside is unquestionably higher, so the payroll hit is slightly easier to stomach. If Strider can get back to being a frontline starter in 2027, his contract will look a lot better. If he gets hurt again or is a shadow of his former self, his contract could end up being the worst one on Atlanta's books.

9. Reynaldo Lopez

No one seems to know what to expect from Reynaldo Lopez going forward, and there is a very real chance that the Braves will be forced to push him back to the bullpen. Complicating matters, his shoulder seems to be a ticking time bomb. Thankfully, Lopez's contract is only $8 million, and it is only for the 2027 season.

8. Mike Yastrzemski

You were likely disappointed in 2026 if you expected Mike Yastrzemski to be an everyday outfielder that might hit 20 home runs. However, for a platoon outfield bat, Yaz wasn't a disaster. It would be better if Atlanta were paying him less than $10 million in 2027, but he is still only a one-year commitment unless they pick up his $7 million club option.

7. Evan Phillips

Paying relievers more than $10 million a year is asking for trouble, and given Evan Phillips' injury history, the contract the Braves just gave him might age poorly. However, for a high-leverage reliever with a track record of success like Phillips, his deal isn't overly egregious, despite it being an overpay.

6. Robert Suarez

If Robert Suarez hadn't JUST missed some time last season with elbow troubles, his contract would rank a couple spots higher. That said, it looks like the Braves have found the guy who will be Raisel Iglesias' heir at closer, and the quality of his stuff gives hope that he will be worth $16 million a year over the next two years.

5. Ozzie Albies

Yes, Ozzie Albies has been declining for a while now, and that is sad. However, this ranking is all about the fact that he is a guy with multiple All-Star appearances, 20-homer power, and who is only making $7 million in the final year of his contract. It just doesn't take much for Albies to be worth that, and odds are high that he will outperform his salary.

4. Ronald Acuña Jr.

The variance with Ronald Acuña Jr. is obviously very high. There does seem to be a good chance he will get bitten by the injury bug again this coming season, but he remains one of the most dangerous hitters in baseball. If he stays healthy, it would not be out of place to see him compete for another MVP. Helping Acuña Jr.'s case is that he is only making $17 million in 2027, and the Braves have a club option for the same amount in 2028. That type of flexibility and upside is tough to come by.

3. Matt Olson

There are not many $20+ million AAV contracts that look good these days, but Matt Olson's deal is an exception. The slugger is showing no signs of slowing down, and is as close to a lock to hit 40+ homers while providing Gold Glove-caliber defence that we have in baseball right now. Getting paid as much as Olson is through 2029 leaves the door open to regression, but the guy hasn't even missed a game in years, let alone slowed down. The $20 million club option for 2030 is just icing on the cake.

2. Chris Sale

We are just putting respect on Chris Sale's name here. At $27 million for the 2027 season, Sale isn't exactly signed at a bargain rate. However, if he continues to be a top-5 pitcher in baseball, that is money well-spent. Atlanta also can bring Sale back in 2028 for $30 million if he continues to pitch his brains out. Flexibility and production? Yep, that gets near top marks.

1. Michael Harris II

We don't think Braves fans fully appreciate what the Braves have in Michael Harris II at the price they got him for. Harris is a consistent 20/20 threat who would have a case as the best defensive center fielder in the National League if Pete Crow-Armstrong didn't exist, and he is just 25 years old and getting better. Oh, and the Braves are only paying him $41 million combined over the last four years of his contract, AND Atlanta has a pair of club options tacked on to the end of the deal.

Add us as a preferred source on Google