It has been sad to see what happened to Austin Riley over the last few years. The Atlanta Braves gave him a hefty extension in 2022, and at the time, everyone thought it was a great move. He was young, well-liked, and finishing his second straight 6+ WAR season. Riley was EXACTLY the kind of player the Braves should have locked up, but it wasn’t long before that choice started to backfire.
The following 2023 season was great, as Riley posted an .861 OPS with 37 home runs. If he just kept doing that or close to it, his contract would look great. Instead, a series of injuries and declining production has put Riley's future in the spotlight. In fact, it is fair to start wondering if 2027 will determine if the Braves should move on from the veteran slugger.
Austin Riley's roster spot on the Braves should not be guaranteed beyond 2027
In a vacuum, it would make sense to move on from Riley right now. Over the last three seasons, Riley's OPS has dropped from .783 to .737 to .654. Once a mortal lock to hit 30+ homers a season, Riley has not eclipsed 20 homers in a season since that fateful 2023 season. While Riley was mostly healthy last season, he also had the third-worst strikeout percentage in all of baseball. He still has the bat speed and average exit velocities you want to see, but that is where the good news ends.
Of course, we don't live in a vacuum, and Riley's contract gives the Braves ample incentive to try and make things work. When you owe a guy $22 million a year through 2032, it is hard to just walk away and write off that investment, especially when a player has the upside that Riley has.
This isn't a knee-jerk reaction to one down season. Riley has been trending in the wrong direction for three years now. Whether it is the combination of injuries he has suffered, the inability to make adjustments under the Braves' current hitting coaches, or both, Riley isn't getting better. If Riley doesn't take a significant step forward in 2027, Atlanta may have no choice but to try and trade him before he becomes literally untradable.
In fact, we may already be very close to that point. Odds are teams aren't exactly lining up to take on $22 million a year for the next six years for the current version of Riley. Atlanta would already have to eat a portion of his contract to get a deal done. It all comes down to 2027, when Riley will either prove he should be a key part of the Braves' future, or prove that the team needs to cut their losses.
