When the Atlanta Braves drafted AJ Gracia with the ninth overall pick, many fans pumped their fists in the air. The Braves do not pick high very often, and that Atlanta opted to spend that pick on a college hitter with real upside in Gracia was legitimately exciting and a departure from what Atlanta had done in years past.
However, recent news about Gracia had some Braves fans panicking at least a little bit. A couple of weeks after the draft, it was reported that Gracia underwent shoulder surgery to repair a torn labrum. That not only guaranteed that Gracia would not be making his pro debut in 2026, but had some worried that Atlanta had gotten a lemon from the draft and made a mistake.
That is not the case. Once you understand how the MLB Draft Combine rules interact with the draft itself and how both sides went about things before he was picked, it becomes very clear that not only did Gracia play through the injury for most of the season (where he was still awesome), but the Braves were completely aware of the injury when they made the pick.
Braves first-round pick AJ Gracia's shoulder injury was an open secret, and shouldn't be a long-term concern
Shoulder injuries can indeed be spooky, and anytime a team adds a hotshot prospect who immediately gets hurt, the tinfoil hats come out and people start losing their minds. While there are times when teams bungle medical reviews and/or serious injuries pop up out of nowhere, that was not the case with Gracia.
Aside from the fact that Gracia's shoulder injury was noted in write-ups before the draft, the MLB Draft Combine was a big clue as well. Gracia participated in the Combine, but he did not consent to a comprehensive medical exam, which would have meant that any team that picked him would have had to offer them at least 75% of the slot value of where they were picked. By not having that exam, Gracia clearly knew that he had an injury and signaled to teams that while he may be hurt, he is also willing to potentially sign for significantly less than 75% slot value depending on where he was picked.
That is where the Braves come in. Gracia knew that his injury dinged his stock a bit, but also probably knew what offers he had on the table and around how much money he was likely to get. In Atlanta's position, they could get a college bat who shouldn't be adversely affected long-term by a known injury AND save a bunch of draft bonus pool money in doing so. When you put it that way, the decision was a no-brainer, and the Braves obviously pulled the trigger on the strategy.
Reasonable people can disagree as to whether going underslot early and then overslot later for prep arms is a sound strategy or not. However, one thing that is certain is Atlanta knew what they were getting into with Gracia's shoulder, but it will be a while before we find out if he was a worthy risk to take.
Add us as a preferred source on Google