Will the Atlanta Braves ever find a long-term answer at shortstop? This vital position has been a longstanding problem for Atlanta since Dansby Swanson left in free agency, and plenty of guys have gotten an opportunity.
Unfortunately, it has been a struggle to find someone consistent enough to provide lasting value up the middle of the diamond for Atlanta. The team's latest experiment has been Jim Jarvis, who won some fans over with a nice three-week stretch in July. Sadly, Jarvis' hot streak came crashing down during the weekend series in Baltimore, and it serves as a stern reminder that shortstop remains a big issue for this club.
Jim Jarvis wants this one back pic.twitter.com/N1OXzi2Nci
— Talkin' Baseball (@TalkinBaseball_) July 26, 2026
Rough series against the Orioles could doom Jim Jarvis' runway as Braves shortstop
It's important not to overreact to just one series in July, but it was an ugly weekend in Baltimore for Jarvis. The normally sure-handed shortstop had multiple defensive lapses and failed to contribute in a meaningful way at the plate. After an 0-5 performance on Sunday, Jarvis' season wRC+ dropped to 96. League average production at shortstop isn't terrible given what Atlanta had been getting, but Jarvis' profile suggests his numbers could come crashing down.
Entering Sunday, Jarvis had a .318 wOBA and .410 slugging percentage. Unfortunately, Jarvis' xwOBA entering Sunday was .279, and his xSLG was .344. Additionally, Jarvis is walking at near Michael Harris II levels, and as we know, Jarvis does not provide the same power or defense to offset that issue like Money Mike does.
Jarvis has earned a spot on this team for now, but once Ha-Seong Kim returns from injury, the Braves will likely turn back to the veteran. Obviously, given Kim's struggles this year, his chance to regain the starting shortstop gig will not last too long if he continues to struggle. August very well could be a battle between Jarvis and Kim to determine which player will man the position during the most important time of the season.
The other alternative would be sticking Dubòn at shortstop. Although it hurts his ability to bounce around the outfield, especially considering that priority number one should be keeping Ronald Acuña Jr. healthy through October.
Maybe Alex Anthopoulos will surprise and trade for someone like Jeremy Peña, but outside of that it's going to be a lot of mixing and matching at shortstop for the remainder of the season. Jarvis didn't play himself out of the mix against Baltimore, but then again, he certainly didn't cement himself as the man for the job either.
Add us as a preferred source on Google