Every offseason, various "experts" come out of the woodwork with trade proposals of questionable validity. Sometimes, they have some basis in truth from previous trade rumors, so they make sense. Others, like one recent trade proposal for the Atlanta Braves from MLB insider Jim Bowden, feel like something constructed in your work fantasy baseball league by the guy who sends 20 trade requests a week and finishes out of the running.
To say Bowden is prolific with his trade speculation is an understatement. Every week, he seems to pull a new set of names and teams out of a hat to throw into the rumor. It is honestly kind of impressive. Most of the time, he at least identifies one team with an actual need in his trade proposals, but they often go off the rails after that.
One case in point comes from one of Bowden's latest columns for The Athletic. The good news is that he does at least try to address a real roster hole for Atlanta at shortstop. The bad news is that he has the Braves trading Didier Fuentes for the A's Jacob Wilson, and there are some pretty fundamental problems with that idea.
No, the Braves should not trade Didier Fuentes for Jacob Wilson, no matter how hard Jim Bowden tries to sell it
Now, the idea of acquiring Wilson in a vacuum isn't a terrible idea. There are some very real questions about the quality of Wilson's contact, but the guy puts the ball in play better than just about any other hitter while being a quality defender (at least when you are looking at Outs Above Average anyway). Assuming that his backloaded contract and toothpick-swinging tendencies are priced into any trade, there are worse ideas out there.
The problem is that Bowden has the Braves trading Fuentes for a guy whose offensive ceiling is extremely low and who just had shoulder surgery, so he might not even be available at the start of the 2027 season. We have seen Fuentes' upside on the Braves' pitching staff, and they want him to play a role in shoring up their rotation depth or, at minimum, continuing his role anchoring Atlanta's bullpen. How does it make sense to use such a valuable trade chip for Wilson, who may never hit enough to be worth his current guaranteed contract and who has very real injury concerns?
Now, should the Braves check in on Wilson as a trade target? Sure! There are not many shortstop options worth having available this offseason, and the most straightforward answer remains trying to push for a reunion with Mauricio Dubon. If the Athletics are reasonable in their asking price, the Braves could do worse. However, if the cost is one of Atlanta's best young arms in Fuentes, who also happens to be very cheap for the foreseeable future, the Braves would do well to ignore Bowden here.
