For years now, the Atlanta Braves have seemed like a natural fit for starting pitcher Sonny Gray, whether through free agency or through trade. Unfortunately, every time the righty has become available, the Braves have found themselves on the outside of the Gray sweepstakes.
This offseason seemed like one of the best opportunities for the Braves to grab the 37-year-old. However, once again, the Braves missed out once again, with Gray deciding to reunite with the Minnesota Twins instead.
Braves fans can cross Sonny Gray off their wish lists. https://t.co/0qW3bu0Qpw
— Mark Bowman (@mlbbowman) November 18, 2026
Braves miss out on Sonny Gray yet again
In his age-36 season, Gray may have just had one of the best years of his career. He started 29 games with a 2.72 ERA and a 3.47 FIP, which lead to him finishing fifth in the AL Cy Young voting. Despite this, the Red Sox opted to decline their $30 million mutual option on Gray, allowing him to hit free agency and become one of the best starting pitching arms available.
MLB Trade Rumors listed Gray as the 13th-best free agent this offseason and expected him to sign to a two-year deal worth $55 million. Because he wasn't going to require a long-term deal, he appeared to be a natural fit for the Braves, who only have Chris Sale firmly anchored in the rotation.
Gray did indeed ink a two-year, $55 million deal as predicted, but the Twins were willing to give him an opt-out after the first season, which may have been the deciding factor for the righty. While we don't know what the Braves were offering (or if they were offering anything at all), Gray returning to Minnesota does at least make sense for the veteran, who spent two seasons with the Twins in 2022 and 2023, and pitched quite well there.
It's unfortunate for the Braves, as Gray would have fit in quite nicely with their rotation, but there are still plenty of rotation options still available. With two weeks until a likely lockout, however, they will likely need to act quickly.
