3 Braves players we'll be glad are gone in 2024 and 3 we wish stayed

Each offseason presents roster turnover. However, some moves we were celebrating more than others. Which players will the Braves miss most in 2024, and which players are we ecstatic are playing elsewhere?

Division Series - Philadelphia Phillies v Atlanta Braves - Game One
Division Series - Philadelphia Phillies v Atlanta Braves - Game One / Kevin D. Liles/Atlanta Braves/GettyImages
1 of 2
Next

Roster turnover from year to year is pretty much a guarantee. The Atlanta Braves won 104 games in the 2023 regular season, but that didn't mean they were going to roll the same guys out there again in 2024. As we know, this offseason Braves GM Alex Anthopoulos has been turning over every stone in an attempt to build a World Series roster.

To make the moves that he has, AA had to depart with some key pieces from the talented 2023 roster. Some guys we will miss more than others, so let's make our best attempt at determining which guys we will be happy are playing elsewhere in 2024, and which players we wish still had on a Braves uniform.

3 Braves players we won't be missing

Division Series - Philadelphia Phillies v Atlanta Braves - Game Two
Division Series - Philadelphia Phillies v Atlanta Braves - Game Two / Matthew Grimes Jr./Atlanta Braves/GettyImages

Kirby Yates

The veteran reliever pitched a boatload of high-leverage innings for Atlanta last year. And just about every single outing felt stressful to watch as a fan. It's not that Yates was ineffective last season, because he wasn't, it is more about his flaw.

That being the big no-no for all relief pitchers...walks. Yates posted a 14.6 BB% last year, which is just entirely too high for a high-leverage reliever. This is why he had a -0.1 fWAR despite having a 3.28 ERA in just over 60 innings.

Those command issues are precisely why the Braves declined his $5.5 million option for 2024, and allowed him to hit free agency instead. Yates would go on to sign with the reigning World Series champion Texas Rangers in early December.

Jared Shuster

Former first round pick in 2020, Jared Shuster never felt like a prospect many fans could get behind. His very hittable fastball, and inability to strikeout guys didn't give him much of a ceiling as a member of the Braves rotation.

Yes, he impressed at Spring Training last year, but Shuster was only on the 2023 Opening Day roster because of the injuries elsewhere in the rotation. Those injuries are exactly why he was pressed into 11 starts last year, all of which felt more uninspiring than the last.

Now a member of the Chicago White Sox thanks to the deal that brought Aaron Bummer to Atlanta, we wish Shuster success in the windy city. However if he wants to lower his 6.13 xFIP and 5.81 ERA from 2023, he's going to have to figure out how to punch more guys out at the major league level.

Eddie Rosario

This one even hurts to type out. It's not that Braves fans will be glad Rosario is gone, because Eddie will always be beloved in Atlanta for what he did in the 2021 postseason. It's more about the excitement of new left fielder Jarred Kelenic and his huge potential.

At this point we knew who Eddie Rosario was right now in his career. A streaky left-handed bat who you couldn't commit to full-time against LHP's, and a bad defender in LF (despite being nominated for a Gold Glove).

Those dull areas of 32 year-old Eddie Rosario's game, were just too much to justify picking up his $9 million club option for 2024. Especially, when you consider Alex Anthopoulos was able to acquire the Braves potential left fielder of the future for a bargain. It was just time to move in a new direction, and right now you're seeing why AA is as brilliant as they come. Kelenic is getting rave reviews about fitting into the clubhouse, while our 2021 postseason hero remains a free agent looking for a new squad to suit up for.

Only time will tell if Kelenic lives up to the production the Braves desire in left field, as well as exactly where and how well Eddie Rosario plays in 2024. However, Braves fans do know one thing, and that is Atlanta will always have a special place in their hearts for super Eddie Rosario.


The Braves are always making moves to win and you can do the same thanks to FanDuel. Just sign up, deposit $10 or more and then bet $5 or more on ANY team to win this week. If your team wins, you'll get $150 in bonus bets! Sign up with FanDuel with this House That Hank Built link today.

3 Braves players we wish stayed

Kevin Pillar

The 2024 Atlanta Braves roster is about as stacked as they come. However, if you were to single out one flaw, the questionable bench depth is a conversation to be had. Last season, the Braves had the luxury of having the prototypical fourth outfielder you want each season.

Kevin Pillar filled that role beautifully in 2024, platooning with Rosario often, as well as springing into action anytime Ronald or Michael Harris II had a small nagging injury. For this upcoming season, Pillar is currently fighting for a roster spot with the White Sox.

That leaves a big void in the Braves bench as to who becomes the first outfield option if one of the starters goes down. That may feel like a question mark right now just looking at the roster, but if Forrest Wall continues to slug like he has thus far in the spring, we may not feel so sour about Pillar's departure in 2024.

Michael Tonkin

If you were to survey Braves fans for an unsung hero in 2023, a lot of people would have thrown around Michael Tonkin's name as a suggestion. His numbers weren't even out of this world, but his ability to eat up innings is something that will be missed.

Incredibly, Tonkin pitched 80 innings out of the bullpen last season. Right now, the Braves don't seem to have that clear cut bullpen innings eater, that is unless you consider Jackson Stephens primed to step back into that role.

However, the bullpen is very deep so this of course can change. Especially, if we get down the road and Reynaldo Lopez isn't making any starts, and has morphed into a multi-inning weapon to lean on.

Nicky Lopez

We end with a name that wasn't even a Brave for the full 2023 season. Atlanta acquired Nicky Lopez from the Royals at last year's trade deadline, but man did he immediately fit in. When you talk about building a great bench on a ball club, Lopez would be the exact type player to pop into your mind.

An excellent, versatile glove, Lopez's ability to handle multiple defensive positions and excel at that makes him a coveted player for a lot of teams. I'm sure the Braves would have loved to keep him, but in their aforementioned trade to get Aaron Bummer from Chicago, the White Sox made sure to get Nicky Lopez in that deal.

The White Sox were the worst defensive team in baseball last year, so it's no wonder they coveted a player like Lopez for their 2024 squad. Given the state of the Braves bench as currently constructed, many fans will probably feel a little down when turn on the sports highlight shows to see Lopez making web gems in the windy city.

More from House That Hank Built

manual

Next