Skip to main content

5 free agent Silver Slugger Award winners the Braves should avoid this offseason

ByEric Cole
Jul 12, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA;  Pittsburgh Pirates designated hitter Marcell Ozuna (24) celebrates his solo home run while wearing a welders hood in the dugout against the Milwaukee Brewers during the fourth inning at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
Jul 12, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Pirates designated hitter Marcell Ozuna (24) celebrates his solo home run while wearing a welders hood in the dugout against the Milwaukee Brewers during the fourth inning at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

One of the best ways to understand how good a hitter is is to ask their peers where they stand. While the Silver Slugger Awards don't have players voting, they ARE tabulated by votes from MLB managers and coaches. That is far from perfect, but it does serve as an important pulse check as to the perceptions of a hitter around MLB at a given point in time. The Atlanta Braves will likely use Silver Sluggers as a data point in their search for bats this offseason, but it should not be the primary factor.

The issue with any award is that it follows a player around, even when they no longer deserve the label. It is just easy to dream on a guy when you have seen them win a Cy Young or Silver Slugger or MVP before. However, in this free agent market, there are some former hardware recipients that Atlanta should avoid.

Here are the former Silver Slugger Award winners that the Braves need to avoid this offseason

The only qualification here is that a free agent hitter must have won a Silver Slugger Award in the past. Whether they won for the first time in this year's Silver Slugger class or a decade ago, it still counts.

Gary Sanchez

We could see a scenario this offseason where the Braves try to trade Sean Murphy to free up some space on their payroll. If they are successful, they will be in the market for a backup catcher, and 2017 Silver Slugger Gary Sanchez's prodigious power and experience could be tempting. However, Sanchez has had exactly one decent season since 2019 and is getting old. If the Braves want a new backup catcher this offseason, a reunion with Travis d'Arnaud (also a former Silver Slugger winner makes more sense than Sanchez.

Carlos Santana

The Braves signed Carlos Santana last season, and they like to stash aging sluggers in Triple-A for a rainy day. In that sense, Santana does fit what Atlanta tends to do each offseason. However, Santana hasn't been the hitter he was when he won his Silver Slugger in 2019 for many years now, and the Braves just released the veteran in August last year. At this point, there is no indication Sanchez has anything left of value to warrant the Braves taking that chance again.

Jeff McNeil

Any likelihood that Jeff McNeil is even considered will come down to whether or not the Braves re-sign Mauricio Dubon. However, even if Dubon does move on, the Braves shouldn't give McNeil a shot. His bat is mediocre in the best of times, he doesn't play a position the Braves need to address, and he will probably cost real money to sign. At almost 35 years old, McNeil doesn't check enough boxes when compared to other options that might actually help the Braves this offseason.

Cedric Mullins

If Cedric Mullins could replicate his 2021 Silver Slugger season with the Orioles, the Braves would be silly not to consider him. However, there is no evidence Mullins will ever be that player again, as he has a combined .696 OPS across the five seasons since his win, including a .628 OPS with the Rays in 2026. Other than on a minor league deal, Mullins doesn't make much sense for the Braves.

Marcell Ozuna

It is honestly hard to envision Marcell Ozuna playing in MLB at all again, although a late-season stop overseas or in the independent leagues might happen. However, in the interest of making sure that we are on the record: no, the Braves should absolutely not reunite with Ozuna. No ifs, ands, or buts.

Add us as a preferred source on Google