Atlanta Braves tough decisions: Johan Camargo does he stay or play AAA?

BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS - SEPTEMBER 01: Johan Camargo #17 of the Atlanta Braves celebrates after scoring a run against the Boston Red Sox during the eighth inning at Fenway Park on September 01, 2020 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Maddie Meyer/Getty Images)
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS - SEPTEMBER 01: Johan Camargo #17 of the Atlanta Braves celebrates after scoring a run against the Boston Red Sox during the eighth inning at Fenway Park on September 01, 2020 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Maddie Meyer/Getty Images)
2 of 3
Atlanta Braves
Atlanta Braves utility man Johan Camargo is a fan favorite, but will he be on the bench to start the season? (Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)

After his successful 2017 season with the Atlanta Braves, Camargo adjusted his swing, most likely in an attempt to increase his average launch angle. From one point of view it worked, but overall, the change was a wash.

What changed?

According to StatCast, Camargo average exit velocity remained relatively steady at 88 mph in 2017 and 88.1 mph in 2018, but he increased his average launch angle from 9.5° to 12 .6°.  The result was an increase in his fly ball rate of 4.5% at the expense of his line drive rate (-2%) and his ground ball rate (-2.8%). Those increases led more home runs than projected, but fewer doubles.

Camargo smacked 21 doubles and four homers in 2017. At that pace, a simple projection would give Camargo eight homers and 40 doubles in 2018 for a total of 48 XBH. His final line included 27 doubles and 19 homers, a total of 46 XBH. He effectively converted some doubles into homers and nudged the warning track outs over the fence. but his success didn’t carry over into 2019.

Don’t blame or credit the pitchers

Pitchers haven’t significantly changed the way they pitched the Atlanta Braves’ utility man since his rookie year. Aside from the slight drop in FB and increase in breaking balls that most rookies see in their sophomore year, the pitch-mix he faced is effectively the same, but he’s not doing much with them.

No. % BA EV LA WHIFF % Put Away %
2019 Fastballs 473 53 .260 87.7 13 17.2 14.3
2018 Fastballs 1141 54.9 .300 88.9 15 19.4 14
2017 Fastballs 570 60.2 .301 89.4 11 16.2 15.3
2019 Breaking 238 26.7 .200 85.5 16 30.7 18
2018 Breaking 534 25.7 .208 86.9 7 28.8 23
2017 Breaking 194 20.5 .309 86.4 12 25 22.1
2019 Offspeed 182 20.4 .200 86.4 -1 38.7 17.5
2018 Offspeed 403 19.4 .286 87.2 13 42.3 19.1
2017 Offspeed 183 19.3 .288 86.3 4 41 25

Camargo’s timing is awful. StatCast shows an increase in mishit pitches since 2018 and a resulting decrease in exit velocity and launch angle.

Yr WK% TOP% UNDR% FL/BRN% EV LA
2017 4.7 33.2 20.7 29.5 88.1 9.5
2018 1.9 34.0 25.1 26.5 88.1 12.6
2019 3.2 36.3 27.9 23.7 86.9 11.1
2020 2.4 42.4 27.1 17.6 87.3 11.2

His peripherals point out that Camargo’s swing isn’t working; worm-killers (burners) that shot through the infield in 2017 and 18 became softly hit ground ball outs. His bloop hits from hump-back line drives (flares), that once fell in front of outfielders turned into popups and outs.

Camargo can still turn on a mistake fastball and drive it, but he’s seeing fewer mistakes.

The most frustrating part for Atlanta Braves’ fans is seeing Camargo come through in critical situations then vanish for the routine plate appearances.

Schedule