Atlanta Braves Roster Decisions Loom: Bourn or Swisher, Who Stays?
Before you vote in this poll, remember that neither of these players will likely generate over 350 plate appearances this season, even in the event of injury. Both have expensive options tied to plate appearances and the Braves definitely do not want to carry either of these guys next season. We’re speaking from a bench/supplemental perspective, and given the nature of the roster as it stands, there will be lots of platoons and tandems already at other positions like second base, third base, and possibly even left field.
That being said, who do you like for the roster? I’m personally going with Michael Bourn, as I value defense from my bench and the ability to play center field. Guys like Matt Wisler will thrive with a great outfield defense all around. I also think Swisher would be easier to potentially trade, especially to an AL team that could part time DH him if need be. I’d also argue that in the event that the Braves need a Nick Swisher type, one already exists on the 40 man roster in Joey Terdoslavich. It’s obvious the Braves have never handled his development that well, even after trading their entire outfield last offseason, but he is a switch hitter with a bit of power that can handle the corner outfield and first base positions if need be. Of course, one could say Bonifacio is very similar to Bourn, but I view Bonifacio as an infielder first. It’s also likely that the Braves might outright release one of them, as the Kelly Johnson signing must come with a corresponding 40 man roster move.
Neither will be easy to get rid of, but for the current state of the Braves, I have to go with Bourn almost every time.